Employee Suggestion Programs Obsolete?

There are many who would agree with the title of this article. There are as many, if not more, who would disagree. Let’s re-frame the question. Do employee suggestion programs work, or do they not work! The answer is YES.

Maybe we should re-frame the answer as well. It’s not the suggestion programs which work or don’t work. It’s the organization using such programs which fails or succeeds.

While many companies have discontinued formal suggestion programs for a variety of reasons, other organizations have reported extraordinary success by tapping the capabilities of their work force.

We’ve had the opportunity to witness first hand the true impact of an effective suggestion program working with various chapters of the Employee Involvement Association (EIA) across the country. As a result of what we’ve seen first hand, we’ve decided to share examples of employee contributions, the impact on organizations, and tips and tools to create, support and strengthen internal programs.

Let’s start by examining some history.

The idea of workplace suggestions began 288 years ago in Japan. You’d think we would have fine-tuned this powerful force by now, wouldn’t you? Well, some have and those particular groups have benefited beyond all expectations. However, here we are almost 300 years later, and only 3% of U.S companies have effective suggestion programs. Everyone talks about them. Few produce results. Sounds like a classic example of “the knowing-doing gap.”

Sharing the results of a survey conducted by “Office Team,” USA Today says: “Only 38% of working men and women feel their managers are willing to listen to new ideas and suggestions for improvement.” True or not, that perception will hinder any efforts to create, support, and benefit from any suggestion program efforts.

However, the 3% that have established effective suggestion programs have certainly achieved a return on their investment far beyond the time and effort involved.

Let’s examine a few examples of those that swear by suggestions programs.

  • Harley-Davidson saved $3,000,000 in 30 days!
  • The U.S. Army got 530 ideas in three weeks!
  • Holly Farms identified $1,000,000 in savings!
  • Eaton Corp. gained 944 ideas from 113 people reaching 100% participation!
  • Parker Hannifin Corp. got 499 ideas from 103 employees!
  • National Semiconductor saved $3,600,000 using a suggestion campaign!
  • The U.S. Park Service made more than 12,000 suggestions with an approval rate of 75%!

Employees Buy an Airplane with Savings

One of the biggest success stories relating to employee suggestions comes from American Airlines (AA) in Fort Worth, Texas. AA ran a year-long suggestion program called “IdeAAs in Flight.” At the end of the year, it purchased a $50.3 million Boeing 757 with the money it saved from the employee suggestion program. AA receives an estimated $55 million a year from its employee suggestion program and reinvests $15 million back into the employees suggestion program.

A Gamble Pays Off

Randy White, an employee of Oregon State Lottery, submitted a suggestion to his manager after finding a solution to upgrade video-lottery terminal equipment so the equipment would accept the new currency issued that year. Randy recommended replacing 2,500 components in terminals at $12.50 each, compared to the manufacturer’s proposal of $450 per terminal. Randy saved the State of Oregon $1,200,672 (one million, two hundred thousand, six hundred and seventy-two dollars) and was awarded $5,000.

Quick Turnaround

Heartland Foods, a Minnesota turkey processor, received 49 ideas from employees in the first four months of a suggestion program. After implementing just 20 of those ideas, the company saved $40,000 in the first year.

Overwhelming Response

W.R. Grace, a specialty chemical manufacturer in Atlanta, saw its suggestion program generate 1,800 ideas from just 55 employees. It implemented more than half of them for a total savings of $125,000.

Shocking ROI

When South Carolina Electric and Gas set up a suggestion program, employees submitted 130 ideas during the first nine months. One of those ideas paid for the program tenfold.

Your organization has a source of talent that’s waiting to be tapped for new ideas. Employees are that source. Get out there and get inside their heads. Set up a suggestion program and tackle it with the same planning and dedication you would expend on any other major project. If you offer enough recognition and set up the right environment, the results will amaze you.

About Harry K. Jones

Harry K. Jones is a motivational speaker and consultant for AchieveMax®, Inc., a company of professional speakers who provide custom-designed seminars, keynote presentations, and consulting services. Harry's top requested topics include change management, customer service, creativity, employee retention, goal setting, leadership, stress management, teamwork, and time management. For more information on Harry's presentations, please call 800-886-2629 or fill out our contact form.

4 thoughts on “Employee Suggestion Programs Obsolete?

  1. I’m been trying to implement this program in my company but i didn’t have that success results, after 3 weeks i received a real one and 4 complains.

    Is any suggestion can help me to increase the amount of suggestions?

  2. Sorry it took me so long to get back to you. I’ve been on the road. Under separate cover, I’m sending you some information which should impact your efforts in a positive way. Please keep me posted as to your progress.
    Harry K. Jones

  3. Hello Harry, I wonder how you feel about smaller financial rewards or puttin maximums on the reqrd. The concern is being able to accurately realize the savings gained, since there may be other factors at play which alos contributed to a savings (g process streamlining). One thought was to pay the employee a portion of the reward when the suggestion is accepted and them, haaving them on the implementation team, pay them the rest once the suggestion is successfully implemented.

    • Hi,
      Your suggestion of paying the employee a portion of the reward when the suggestion is accepted and then, having them on the implementation team, pay them the rest once the suggestion is successfully implemented is currently being used by a large number of our clients and seems to be working very well. Getting the emplpoyee involved with the implementation has proven to be very successful. Utilizing this approach has also often motivated fellow employee to get involved as well. I would suggest you give it a shot. Be sure to include EXPECTATIONS, ACCOUNTABILITY and CONSEQUENCES to insure the ROI you seek. Good Luck! Harry K.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *